| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Virginia | Todd DeSorbo | 501.5 | Texas | 390.5 | Knoxville |
| 2022 | Virginia | Todd DeSorbo | 551.5 | Texas | 406 | Atlanta |
| 2021 | Virginia | Todd DeSorbo | 491 | NC State | 354 | Greensboro |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Stanford | Greg Meehan | 456 | California | 418 | Austin |
| 2018 | Stanford | Greg Meehan | 593 | California | 373 | Columbus |
| 2017 | Stanford | Greg Meehan | 526.5 | California | 366 | Indianapolis |
| 2016 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 414 | Stanford | 395 | Georgia Tech |
| 2015 | California | Teri McKeever | 513 | Georgia | 452 | Greensboro |
| 2014 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 528 | Stanford | 402.5 | Minneapolis |
| 2013 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 477 | California | 393 | Indianapolis |
| 2012 | California | Teri McKeever | 412.5 | Georgia | 366 | Auburn |
| 2011 | California | Teri McKeever | 424 | Georgia | 394.5 | Texas |
| 2010 | Florida | Gregg Troy | 382 | Stanford | 379.5 | Purdue |
| 2009 | California | Teri McKeever | 411.5 | Georgia | 400.5 | Texas A&M |
| 2008 | Arizona | Frank Busch | 484 | Auburn | 348 | Ohio State |
| 2007 | Auburn | David Marsh/ Doresey Tierney-Walker | 535 | Arizona | 477 | Minnesota |
| 2006 | Auburn | David Marsh/ Doresey Tierney-Walker | 518.5 | Georgia | 515.5 | Georgia |
| 2005 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 609.5 | Auburn | 492 | Purdue |
| 2004 | Auburn | David Marsh | 569 | Georgia | 431 | Texas A&M |
| 2003 | Auburn | David Marsh | 536 | Georgia | 373 | Auburn |
| 2002 | Auburn | David Marsh | 474 | Georgia | 386 | Texas |
| 2001 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 389 | Stanford | 387.5 | Long Island |
| 2000 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 490 | Arizona | 472 | Indianapolis |
| 1999 | Georgia | Jack Bauerle | 504.5 | Stanford | 441 | Georgia |
| 1998 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 422 | Arizona | 378 | Minnesota |
| 1997 | Southern California | Mark Schubert | 406 | Stanford | 395 | Indianapolis |
| 1996 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 478 | SMU | 397 | Michigan |
| 1995 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 497.5 | Michigan | 478.5 | Texas |
| 1994 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 512 | Texas | 421 | Indianapolis |
| 1993 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 649.5 | Florida | 421 | Minnesota |
| 1992 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 735.5 | Texas | 651 | Texas |
| 1991 | Texas | Mark Schubert | 746 | Stanford | 653 | Indianapolis |
| 1990 | Texas | Mark Schubert | 632 | Stanford | 622.5 | Texas |
| 1989 | Stanford | Richard Quick | 610.5 | Texas | 547 | Indianapolis |
| 1988 | Texas | Richard Quick | 661 | Florida | 542.5 | Texas |
| 1987 | Texas | Richard Quick | 648.5 | Stanford | 631.5 | Indianapolis |
| 1986 | Texas | Richard Quick | 633 | Florida | 586 | Arkansas |
| 1985 | Texas | Richard Quick | 643 | Florida | 400 | Alabama |
| 1984 | Texas | Richard Quick | 392 | Stanford | 324 | Indianapolis |
| 1983 | Stanford | George Haines | 418.5 | Florida | 389.5 | Nebraska |
| 1982 | Florida | Randy Reese | 505 | Stanford | 383 | Florida |
