| Year | Champion (Record) | Coach | Score | Runner-Up | Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Johns Hopkins (23-0-2) | Dan Weiler | 2-1 | CWRU | Salem, Va. |
| 2021 | Christopher Newport (22-0-1) | Jamie Gunderson | 2-0 | TCNJ | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Messiah (22-1-3) | Scott Frey | 1-0 | William & Smith | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2018 | Williams (19-1-4) | Michelyne Pinard | 1-1 (3-2 PKs) | Middlebury | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2017 | Williams (22-1-1) | Michelyne Pinard | 1-0 | Chicago | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2016 | Washington-St. Louis (18-2-3) | Jim Conlon | 1-1 (5-4 PKs) | Messiah | Salem, Va. |
| 2015 | Williams (21-1-2) | Michelyne Pinard | 1-0 | Washington-St. Louis | Kansas City, Mo. |
| 2014 | *Lynchburg (26-0-2) | Todd Olsen | 0-0 (4-3 PKs) | Williams | Kansas City, Mo. |
| 2013 | William Smith (23-1-0) | Aliceann Wilber | 2-0 | Trinity (Texas) | San Antonio |
| 2012 | Messiah (24-1-1) | Scott Frey | 1-0 | Emory | San Antonio |
| 2011 | Messiah (23-0-1) | Scott Frey | 3-1 | Wheaton (Ill.) | San Antonio |
| 2010 | Hardin-Simmons (24-0-1) | Marcus Wood | 2-1 | Messiah | San Antonio |
| 2009 | Messiah (25-0-1) | Scott Frey | 1-0 | Washington-St. Louis | San Antonio |
| 2008 | Messiah (24-0-2) | Scott Frey | 5-0 | Wheaton (Ill.) | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2007 | Wheaton (Ill.) (27-0) | Pete Felske | 1-0 | Messiah | Lake Buena Vista, Fla. |
| 2006 | Wheaton (Ill.) (24-2) | Pete Felske | 2-0 | TCNJ | Lake Buena Vista, Fla. |
| 2005 | Messiah (22-0-1) | Scott Frey | 1-0 | TCNJ | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2004 | *Wheaton (IL) (25-1) | Pete Felske | 1-1 (2 ot, pk) | Pugent Sound | Greensboro, N.C. |
| 2003 | Oneonta State (21-1-3) | Tracey Ranieri | 2-1 (ot) | Chicago | Oneonta State |
| 2002 | Ohio Wesleyan (24-0) | Bob Barnes | 1-0 | Messiah | William Smith |
| 2001 | Ohio Wesleyan (22-1) | Bob Barnes | 1-0 | Amherst | Ohio Wesleyan |
| 2000 | TCNJ (23-1) | Joe Russo | 2-1 | Tufts | Tufts |
| 1999 | UC San Diego (19-1-2) | Brian McManus | 1-0 | Macalester | Williams |
| 1998 | Macalester (22-1-1) | John Leaney | 1-0 (4 ot) | TCNJ | Ithaca |
| 1997 | UC San Diego (20-2) | Brian McManus | 1-0 | William Smith | Elizabethtown |
| 1996 | UC San Diego (21-1) | Brian McManus | 2-1 | TCNJ | Amherst |
| 1995 | UC San Diego (19-2) | Brian McManus | 3-0 | Methodist | Richard Stockton |
| 1994 | TCNJ (15-0) | Joe Russo | 4-3 (3 ot) | UC San Diego | UC San Diego |
| 1993 | TCNJ (20-1-3) | Joe Russo | 4-0 | Plymouth State | William Smith |
| 1992 | SUNY Cortland (17-2-3) | Chris Malone | 1-0 | UMass-Dartmouth | Mary Washington |
| 1991 | Ithaca (19-2-3) | Patrick Farmer | 2-0 | Rochester | Plymouth State |
| 1990 | Ithaca (18-5-2) | Patrick Farmer | 1-0 (4 ot, pk) | SUNY Cortland | SUNY Cortland |
| 1989 | UC San Diego (19-1-1) | Brian McManus | 3-2 (3 ot) | Ithaca | UC San Diego |
| 1988 | William Smith (18-1-1) | Aliceann Wilber | 1-0 | UC San Diego | William Smith |
| 1987 | Rochester (18-1) | Terry Gurnett | 1-0 | William Smith | Rochester |
| 1986 | Rochester (13-2-1) | Terry Gurnett | 1-0 | Plymouth State | SUNY Cortland |
*Declared champion on the basis of penalty kicks.
