| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Oklahoma | K.J. Kindler | 198.3875 | Florida | 198.2375 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2022 | Oklahoma | K.J. Kindler | 198.2000 | Florida | 198.0875 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2021 | Michigan | Beverly Plocki | 198.25 | Oklahoma | 198.1625 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | Oklahoma | K.J. Kindler | 198.3375 | LSU | 197.8250 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2018 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 198.0750 | Oklahoma | 198.0375 | St. Louis |
| 2017 | Oklahoma | K.J. Kindler | 198.3875 | LSU | 197.7375 | St. Louis |
| 2016 | Oklahoma | K.J. Kindler | 197.675 | LSU | 197.450 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2015 | Florida | Rhonda Faehn | 197.850 | Utah | 197.800 | Fort Worth, Texas |
| 2014 | Florida, Oklahoma | Rhonda Faehn, K.J. Kindler | 198.175 | LSU | 197.600 | Birmingham, Ala. |
| 2013 | Florida | Rhonda Faehn | 197.575 | Oklahoma | 197.375 | UCLA |
| 2012 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 197.850 | Florida | 197.775 | Georgia Tech |
| 2011 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 197.65 | UCLA | 197.375 | Cleveland |
| 2010 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 197.725 | Oklahoma | 197.25 | Florida |
| 2009 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.825 | Alabama | 197.575 | Nebraska |
| 2008 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.45 | Utah | 197.125 | Georgia |
| 2007 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.85 | Utah | 197.25 | Utah |
| 2006 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.75 | Utah | 196.8 | Oregon State |
| 2005 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.825 | Alabama | 197.4 | Auburn |
| 2004 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 198.125 | Georgia | 197.2 | UCLA |
| 2003 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 197.825 | Alabama | 197.275 | Nebraska |
| 2002 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 197.575 | Georgia | 197.25 | Alabama |
| 2001 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 197.575 | Georgia | 197.4 | Georgia |
| 2000 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 197.3 | Utah | 196.875 | Boise State |
| 1999 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 196.85 | Michigan | 196.55 | Utah |
| 1998 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 197.725 | Florida | 196.35 | UCLA |
| 1997 | UCLA | Valorie Kondos Field | 197.15 | Arizona State | 196.85 | Florida |
| 1996 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 198.025 | UCLA | 197.475 | Alabama |
| 1995 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 196.65 | Alabama, Michigan | 196.425, 196.425 | Georgia |
| 1994 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 196.4 | Alabama | 196.35 | Utah |
| 1993 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 198 | Alabama | 196.825 | Oregon State |
| 1992 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 195.65 | Georgia | 194.6 | Minnesota |
| 1991 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 195.125 | Utah | 194.375 | Alabama |
| 1990 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 194.9 | Alabama | 194.575 | Oregon State |
| 1989 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 192.65 | UCLA | 192.6 | Georgia |
| 1988 | Alabama | Sarah Patterson | 190.05 | Utah | 189.5 | Utah |
| 1987 | Georgia | Suzanne Yoculan | 187.9 | Utah | 187.55 | Utah |
| 1986 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 186.95 | Arizona State | 186.7 | Florida |
| 1985 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 188.35 | Arizona State | 186.6 | Utah |
| 1984 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 186.05 | UCLA | 185.55 | UCLA |
| 1983 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 184.65 | Arizona State | 183.3 | Utah |
| 1982 | Utah | Greg Marsden | 148.6 | Cal State Fullerton | 144.1 | Utah |
