| Year | Champion | Coach | Points | Runner-Up | Points | Host or Site |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2023 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Will Anti | 4,729 | TCU | 4,717 | Ohio State |
| 2022 | Kentucky | Harry Mullins | 4,739 | TCU | 4,736 | Colorado Springs |
| 2021 | Kentucky | Harry Mullins | 4,731 | TCU | 4,722 | Ohio State |
| 2020 | Canceled due to Covid-19 | -- | -- | -- | -- | -- |
| 2019 | TCU | Karen Monez | 4,699 | West Virginia | 4,692 | West Virginia |
| 2018 | Kentucky | Harry Mullins | 4,717 | West Virginia | 4,708 | The Citadel |
| 2017 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,723 | TCU | 4,706 | Ohio State |
| 2016 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,703 | TCU | 4,694 | Akron |
| 2015 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,702 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 4,700 | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| 2014 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,705 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 4,677 | Murray State |
| 2013 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,679 | Kentucky | 4,670 | Ohio State |
| 2012 | TCU | Karen Monez | 4,676 | Kentucky | 4,661 | Ohio State |
| 2011 | Kentucky | Harry Mullins | 4,700 | West Virginia | 4,697 | Columbus State |
| 2010 | TCU | Karen Monez | 4,675 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 4,653 | TCU |
| 2009 | West Virginia | Jon Hammond | 4,643 | Kentucky | 4,638 | TCU |
| 2008 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dan Jordan | 4,662 | Army | 4,652 | Army |
| 2007 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dan Jordan | 4,662 | Army | 4,644 | Alaska-Fairbanks |
| 2006 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dan Jordan | 4,682 | Nebraska | 4,666 | Air Force |
| 2005 | Army | Ron Wigger | 4,659 | Jacksonville State | 4,658 | Nevada |
| 2004 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Glen Dubis | 6,273 | Nevada | 6,185 | Murray State |
| 2003 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dave Johnson | 6,287 | Xavier | 6,197 | Army |
| 2002 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dave Johnson | 6,241 | Kentucky | 6,209 | Murray State |
| 2001 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Dave Johnson | 6,283 | Kentucky | 6,175 | Ohio State |
| 2000 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Randy Pitney | 6,285 | Xavier | 6,156 | VMI |
| 1999 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Randy Pitney | 6,276 | Navy | 6,168 | Norwich |
| 1998 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,214 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 6,211 | Murray State |
| 1997 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,223 | Kentucky | 6,175 | Murray State |
| 1996 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,179 | Air Force | 6,168 | Air Force |
| 1995 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,241 | Air Force | 6,187 | Navy |
| 1994 | Alaska-Fairbanks | Randy Pitney | 6,194 | West Virginia | 6,187 | Murray State |
| 1993 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,179 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 6,169 | VMI |
| 1992 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,214 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 6,166 | Murray State |
| 1991 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,171 | Alaska-Fairbanks | 6,110 | Army |
| 1990 | West Virginia | Marsha Beasley | 6,205 | Navy | 6,101 | Navy |
| 1989 | West Virginia | Edward Etzel | 6,234 | South Florida | 6,180 | Murray State |
| 1988 | West Virginia | Greg Perrine | 6,192 | Murray State | 6,183 | VMI |
| 1987 | Murray State | Elvis Green | 6,205 | West Virginia | 6,203 | Xavier |
| 1986 | West Virginia | Edward Etzel | 6,229 | Murray State | 6,163 | Navy |
| 1985 | Murray State | Elvis Green | 6,150 | West Virginia | 6,149 | Army |
| 1984 | West Virginia | Edward Etzel | 6,206 | East Tennessee State | 6,142 | Murray State |
| 1983 | West Virginia | Edward Etzel | 6,166 | Tennessee Tech | 6,148 | Xavier |
| 1982 | Tennessee Tech | James Newkirk | 6,138 | West Virginia | 6,136 | VMI |
| 1981 | Tennessee Tech | James Newkirk | 6,139 | West Virginia | 6,136 | Army |
| 1980 | Tennessee Tech | James Newkirk | 6,201 | West Virginia | 6,150 | East Tennessee State |
From 1980 to 2004, the championship consisted of 120 shots by each competitor in smallbore, and 40 shots per competitor in air rifle. Since 2005, the championship has consisted of 60 shots for both smallbore and air rifle, equaling a total of 120 shots per team member.
